
Directed by Arthur Penn
Written by Calder Wittingham from a novel by Thomas Berger
1970/US
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime
One of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
Old Lodge Skins: There is an endless supply of white men. There has always been a limited number of human beings.
This tragi-comic story of a man who straddled two worlds holds up well.
The 121-year-old Jack Crabb (Dustin Hoffmann) tells the story of his life to a historian who known only of Jack’s participation in The Battle of Little Big Horn. Most of the movie is in flashback. When he was 10-years-old, Jack Crabb’s parents were murdered by the Pawnee. Jack and his sister are rescued by the Cheyenne tribe. (The word Cheyenne simply means “human being” in their language.) Jack and the Indians take to each other and he becomes the adopted grandson of their leader, Old Lodge Skins (Chief Dan George). Jack gradually becomes far more comfortable in the Cheyenne world than in that of the white man.

In his long life, Jack shuttles between the two worlds. In turn, he is adopted by a churchman and his horny wife (Faye Dunaway); works for a snakeoil salesman (Martin Balsalm); becomes a gunslinger and meets Wild Bill Hickock (Jeff Corey), then a general store proprieter; marries a Swede who is eventually captured by Indians; becomes a muleskinner in Custer’s (Richard Mulligan) cavalry; goes back to the Cheyenne and takes on three sisters as wives; and meets up with Custer again at the Battle of Little Big Horn.

Hoffman does a pretty incredible job aging from around 15 to 121 but all my favorite scenes had Dan George in them. The script gives everyone concerned some sharp dialogue to sling around. I think I would have liked it better if it had been 1/2 hour shorter but it entertained me throughout.
Chief Dan George was nominated for the Best Supporting Actor Oscar.


Missed this one in 1970 . . . .
Me too! It’s not something I will run out to see again but is very entertaining.
For a comedy it has some pretty dark moments, but it is worth noting how different the tone is in the two environments of the movie, the white and the Indian. One is consistently ridiculous while the other is tragic. I am certain this is intentional.
I agree. I think the film was nicely balanced. Otherwise it could have been something like Dances with Wolves, a movie that I can’t help but hate despite all its fans and awards.