The Black Watch (1929)

The Black Watch
Directed by John Ford
Written by James Kevin McGuiness and John Stone from a novel by Talbot Mundy
1929/US
Fox Film Corporation
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

Tagline: Face to Face With the Women He Came to Betray…Duty Urged Him On…Love Held Him Back…A Titanic Struggle of Power and Passion. (Print Ad- Greensburg Daily Tribune, ((Greensburg, Penna.))

John Ford’s first talkie is an impressive technical effort. The script though, hoo-ee!

The famous Highland regiment of the British army has been called up to the front lines of WWI in France. Victor McLaglen is a popular captain in the regiment. But he is suddenly ordered on a top secret mission to India to infiltrate a Muslim terrorist organization which holds many British prisoners and has plans to disrupt the Raj. The mission is extremely dangerous but he can disclose it to no one so all his comrades think he is a coward who is avoiding combat.

His first goal is to get close to Myrna Loy, whom her followers believe is a goddess. Loy’s followers distrust McLaglen but she falls for him because she “has Aryan blood”. Much danger and action follow.

The Scottish part of this movie is classic Ford with lots of male bonding, singing, and sentiment. The Indian section can be described only as politically incorrect high camp. All the actors wear brown face except for Loy with her “Aryan Blood”. She was still in her sinister Oriental phase and her line delivery is a hoot! The technical aspects of the film are unusually polished for this period and there are plenty of extras and lavish costumes and set design. If you can get over the ethnic stereotyping and brown face, you might have a bit of fun with this movie. McLaglen looks so young and attractive! It’s definitely not a must-see.

Born Reckless (1930)

Born Reckless
Directed by John Ford
Written by Dudley Nichols from a novel by Donald Henderson Clarke
1930/US
Fox Film Corporation
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

Ford proves to be less adept at gangster movies than he was at Westerns or war stories.

Mobster Louis Beretti (Edmund Lowe – least Italian looking Italian in cinema) and a couple of his cronies are given the chance to volunteer for duty in WWI as an alternative to time in the slammer. When our hero returns from the front, he tries to go straight. It’s hard since his way of doing so is to open a speakeasy and hang out with the same gang he did before he went away. Drama ensues. With Marguerite Churchill as our hero’s sister.

The WWI parts are more engaging and Ford-like than the later crime melodrama.  Can be watched in full on YouTube for free.  No trailer or clips though.

From a movie premier in 1929 or 1930. Footage includes: Dorothy Sebastian, Karl Dane, H.B. Warner, Nils Asther, Robert Montgomery, Anita Page, Norma Shearer, John Gilbert, Bebe Daniels and Ben Lyon, Erich Von Stroheim, James Kirkwood, Betty Compson, James Cruze, Jack Holt, George O’Brien, Olive Borden, Janet Gaynor, Charles Farrell, Lois Moran, Buster Collier (William Collier, Jr.), Joseph Schildkraut, Maurice Chevalier, Nancy Carroll, Edmund Lowe & Lilyan Tashman, Joan Bennett, Norma Shearer again with Irving Thalberg, Harold Lloyd, Bessie Love, Ivan Lebedeff, Jack Oakie, Georgie Stone, Buster Collier again, Hoot Gibson, Gary Cooper, Bessie Love again, Warner Baxter, Lila Lee, Buron Fitts (L.A. County District Attorney elected in November 1928), Helene Chadwick, George O’Brien and Olive Borden again, Mary Brian, Ivan Lebedeff again, Lilyan Tashman and Edmund Lowe again, John Boles, Bebe Daniels again, Ben Lyon again, Hoot Gibson with Sally Eilers, Billie Dove, Betty Compson again (Roscoe Arbuckle appears briefly behind Betty Compson, then cutaway), Joe E. Brown, Ruby Keeler and Al Jolson, William Bakewell, Mary Brian with unidentified escort, Regis Toomey, Norma Shearer again, and Clara Bow.

 

Bucking Broadway (1917)

Bucking Broadway
Directed by John Ford
Written by George Hively
1917/US
Universal Film Manufacturing Company
IMDb page
First viewing/Criterion Channel

Unnamed cowboy: He’s only a simple ranch hand; it must be more than friendship.

John Ford was making solid Westerns almost from the get-go.

Cheyenne Harry (Harry Carey) is the pride of the cowboys on the horse ranch where he works. He is in love with the ranch owner’s adorable daughter Helen (Molly Malone). The father is enthusiastic and a date is set.

But before the two can be united, a city slicker arrives looking for young horses to buy. He soon starts sweet talking Molly and eventually convinces her to run away with him to New York City. It doesn’t take Molly long to become disillusioned with her beau and then it is Harry to the rescue.

This is a sweet romance with some trademark Ford touches, including magnificent use of locations. It is not the baffling Western mystery promised in the poster however.

Numerous free full versions of the movie are currently on YouTube.  No trailer or clips however so here is a tribute to Harry Carey, Ford’s favorite leading man until John Wayne came along.

Seas Beneath (1931)

Seas Beneath
Directed by John Ford
Written by Dudley Nichols from a story by James Parker Jr.
1931/US
Fox Film Corporation
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

Everyone’s got to make one submarine drama in their life. — Kevin Macdonald

John Ford had to make several submarine dramas.  This is a pretty good one.

The story takes place toward the end of WWI. Cmdr. Robert Kingsley (George O’Brien) captains a “mystery ship” – a battleship disguised as a schooner in order to lure German U-boats into range of the US submarine traveling alongside and the ship’s hidden big guns. The Germans are known to lurk in the seas around the Canary Islands so the commander heads there.

Unfortunately, he grants his crew liberty in town under strict orders not to drink hard liquor or fraternize with women. These rules are very soon broken by the entire crew including Cmdr. Bob, who begins a flirtation with pretty Anna Marie (Marion Lessing). Anna Marie is the sister of the captain of the U-boat unbeknownst to him. One of the other officers succumbs to the charms of a Spanish Mata Hari. Will the ship’s mission be thwarted?  With John Loden as a German officer.

This film has plenty of manly banter and a fair amount of singing, trademarks of Ford. It also reflects his love for the navy and sailors which would be expressed throughout his career.

 

Just Pals (1920)

Just Pals
Directed by John Ford
Written by John McDermott and Paul Schofield
1920/US
Fox Film Corporation
IMDb page
First viewing/YouTube

Bill: [to Bim] They ain’t nothin’ the matter with you, is there? You didn’t go to school, did you? Then why in hell send me?

A sentimental story told well by John Ford and company.

The setting is a small Western town.  Buck Jones plays Bim.  He is scorned and ridiculed by all for his laziness and tattered clothes but he has a heart of the purest gold.  He has a crush on local schoolmarm Mary (Helen Ferguson).  She is being courted by bank clerk Harvey Cahill (William Buckley).

One day, Bim rescues Bill (George Stone), a boy of about ten, after he is forcibly ejected from the train he has hooked a ride on.  They become close pals and Bim takes on a fatherly attitude.  This includes trying to bathe his charge and sending him to school.

Bill gets injured and the local doctor takes him in.  When the doctor’s wife learns there is a large reward for recovery of a runaway fitting Bill’s description, the couple set about separating the two pals.  In the meantime, Mary is in terrible trouble after she innocently did a favor for the bank clerk, who is a complete rat.  Things get more exciting as the movie draws to a close.

You wouldn’t suspect that the director of this film was John Ford if you didn’t read the credits.  On the other hand, the story is very well told and the actors are all charming.

Tribute to John Ford

**************

My next adventure in cinema will be an in-depth exploration of John Ford’s filmography.  I still plan to move into 1978 soon but those films are probably not ones my husband will enjoy.  I will only review the Ford films here if I have not done so before.  If you are curious, you could follow my Instagram account at @flickersintime.

I also watched Ford’s eight-minute documentary on the fate of Torpedo Squad 8 which lost all 15 of its torpedo bombers during the battle of Midway.  This is done by showing smiling young men full of life preparing their bombers for battle and then listing the names and ranks of the dead. Very simple and devastating.

Blondie (1938)

Blondie
Directed by Frank R. Strayer
Written by Richard Flourney based on the comic strip by Chic Young
1938/US
Columbia Pictures
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

“I’m not offended by all the dumb blonde jokes because I know I’m not dumb… and I also know that I’m not blonde.” ~ Dolly Parton

For some reason I had always assumed that these were just B movie filler.  Imagine my delight at how downright funny this was!

In this one, Dagwood (Arthur Lake) is in the hot water again when a loan he has foolishly co-signed comes due. Mr. Dithers (Jonathan Hale) gives him one day to win a large contract from cranky H. P. Hazlip (Gene Lockhart) or be fired. His furniture and marriage are on the line. As usual Blondie (Penny Singleton) saves the day, helped by Dagwood and H.P.’s mutual love of tinkering.

The plot isn’t important. It’s all the funny interactions of Blondie, Dagwood, Baby Dumpling, and Daisy the Dog whom the actors make leap out of the comic strip. Don’t wait as long as I did to find out what this series was about.

 

They Made Me a Criminal (1939)

They Made Me a Criminal
Directed by Busby Berkeley
Written by Sig Herzig from a novel by Bertram Millhauser and Beulah Marie Dix
1939/US
Warner Bros.
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime (free to Members)

Speed: She took eight gallons. That’s a dollar twenty-eight.

Wow! Here I have been happily traversing through the 30’s and all of a sudden run into a movie that would have felt at home in 1946.

John Garfield plays Johnny Bradfield, your standard anti-hero champion boxer. He gets drunk at an after-bout party and reveals that the mother he is constantly sending greetings to does not exist. A reporter is eager to smear this all over the press. Johnny slugs him, the reporter slugs back and, while Johnny is unconscious, his manager beans the reporter with a bottle and kills him. The manager and Garfield’s girlfriend Goldie (Ann Sheridan) flee the scene leaving Johnny holding the bag. They both die in a fiery crash and the police believe the male victim was Garfield. That is all but Detective Monty Phelan (Claude Rains).

Bradfield’s lawyer steals all his money and he sets off with $250. Before long he is a tramp traveling under the name Jack Dolan. He finally settles on a date farm being run as a reform school for the Dead End Kids by pretty blonde Peggy {Gloria Dickson).  But can Jack maintain his disguise forever?  With May Robson as Peggy’s mother.

This isn’t among the best film noirs ever made but it is impressive for being so early in the cycle. Garfield looks so young! James Wong Howe’s cinematography certainly doesn’t hurt. Worth a watch.

 

The Shopworn Angel (1938)

The Shopworn Angel
Directed by H.C. Potter
Written by Waldo Salt based on a story by Dana Burnet
1938/US
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime Rental

Pvt. William ‘Texas’ Pettigrew: Dying’s a lot like being in love. You can’t imagine it until it’s right on top of you.

The story is set in 1917 New York. Margaret Sullavan is a musical star on Broadway. She keeps company with rich, sophisticated Walter Pidgeon. James Stewart is a soldier on leave as he waits for orders to be shipped to the frontlines in France. He is as naive as they come, hailing from a horse ranch in Texas. James meets Margaret by chance and soon has a massive crush on her. She humors him out of sort of a sense of duty, though clearly a sort of affection develops. I will say no more but the plot and its resolution seemed very odd to me.

I think this was supposed to be a tearjerker but the way the love triangle was handled failed to move me. Anyway, the stars shone and it was an entertaining movie.

Major spoiler

Sidewalks of London (1938)

Sidewalks of London (AKA “St. Martins Lane”)
Directed by Tim Whelan
Written by Clemence Dane
1938/UK
Mayflower Pictures Corporation
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

Charles Staggers: There ain’t no answer. You’re after justice and logic. There ain’t no justice, and there ain’t no logic. The world ain’t made that way. Everything’s luck, see. And good temper. And if you can take a joke. The whole of life’s a joke.

I loved this movie so much!

Charles Staggers (Charles Laughton) is a street performer who does dramatic recitations in London’s theater district for tips. (One of the delights of this movie is how badly he acts while doing these recitations). One night gutter snipe Liberty (just the one name “like Garbo” (Vivien Leigh)) steals sixpence from him. Later he runs into her at a food stall where he catches her stealing high-society Harley Prentiss’s (Rex Harrison) gold cigarette case. Instead of reporting her to the cops, he takes her in hand. Then he discovers what an absolutely lovely singer and dancer she is. He puts together an new act featuring her dancing to the singing of himself and a couple of other buskers.

 

Starrett had turned the cigarette case over to the police in hopes of getting a reward. This reunites Liberty with Prentiss, who is a composer for the musical theater. Leigh’s star rises as Laughton slowly falls apart.


I thought this movie was an absolute delight. Leigh may never have been so downright adorable. She really dances beautifully. And it need hardly be said that Laughton is excellent both as a comedian and as a pathetic figure. There’s a part where he is reciting Kipling’s “If” where he shifts from bombast to emotion and back again that is a wonder. It’s a bittersweet story that grabbed me and didn’t let go. Highly recommended.

Anna Karenina (1935)

Anna Karenina
Directed by Clarence Brown
Written by Clemence Dance and Salka Viertel from the novel by Lev Tolstoy
1935/US
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer
IMDb page
First viewing/Amazon Prime rental

“If you love me as you say you do,’ she whispered, ‘make it so that I am at peace.”
― Leo Tolstoy, Anna Karenina

This is my favorite novel.  No film could match the images in my mind or do it justice, IMO.

Anna (Greta Garbo) is married to the much-older Count Alexis Karenin (Basil Rathbone), a pedantic bureaucrat.  They have a little son Sergei (Freddie Bartholomew) who is the light of Anna’s life.  Anna’s brother Stepan has been caught in an affair by his wife Dolly.  Anna travels from St. Petersburg to Moscow to make peace.  She shares a carriage on the train with the mother of Count Alexis Vronsky (Fredric March), a young soldier who has been courting Dolly’s younger sister, Kitty. (Maureen O’Sullivan).

Anna is successful in reconciling her brother and sister-in-law.  She goes to a ball where Kitty is expecting a proposal from Vronsky .  But Vronsky wants only to dance with Anna and the die is cast.  He follows her to St. Petersburg.  Kitty, who had the same night rejected a proposal from Count Levin, grows ill from humiliation and heartbreak. The Kitty-Levin story, which makes up about half of the novel and provides a needed counterpoint to the Anna-Vronsky affair, is dropped almost entirely by the movie at this point.

The lovers cannot resist temptation.  Karenin is remarkably tolerant, seeking only to avoid scandal.  But Anna reveals the depth of her feelings in public when Vronsky is thrown from his horse and Karenin seeks a divorce.  In revenge, he also asks for sole custody of the son.  Although extramarital affairs are common in St. Petersburg high society, they are strictly recreational.  By openly defying the rules, Anna becomes an outcast.  Things go downhill from there.  Then Vronsky announces that he is going to rejoin his regiment to fight the Turks, building to the well-known climax of the novel which I will not reveal here.

The chemistry between Garbo and March isn’t great and Garbo’s acting seems particularly like posing here. Of all the adaptations I have seen, I would suggest Anna Karenina (1948) with Vivien Leigh, Ralph Richardson, and Kieron Moore. The Russian adaptation
Anna Karenina (1967) is lavish but I found it lackluster. This one has all those great MGM production values and Garbo would make any man lose his heart.