Category Archives: Movie Reviews

Reviews of movies I have seen.

Sergeant Rutledge (1960)

Sergeant Rutledge
Directed by John Ford
Written by James Warner Bellah and Willis Goldbeck
1960/USA
John Ford Productions
First viewing/Netflix rental

[box] 1st Sgt. Braxton Rutledge: Soldier can never think by his heart, ma’am. He got to think by the book.[/box]

Two years before To Kill a Mockingbird, John Ford gave us this courtroom drama/Western about a Buffalo solider accused of raping and killing a white woman.

The story is told in a mixture of scenes from the trial of Sgt. Rutledge (Woody Strode) and flashbacks based on witness testimony.  When reshuffled into chronological order, it begins with the discovery of the bodies of a young woman, who had been raped, and her father, the commander of a frontier outpost, who was killed with a service revolver.

Then Lt. Tom Cantrell (Jeffrey Hunter) meets Mary Beecher (Constance Towers) on a train that is taking her home after twelve years in the East and Tom to the fort where he is stationed.  After falling in love, the pair part at the station closest to Mary’s father’s ranch. There, Mary discovers that the station attendant has been killed by an Apache’s arrow.  Her father has not shown up to meet her.  She meets Sgt. Rutledge who is very nervous to be in the company of a white woman but protects her valiently.

It turns out Rutledge has been wounded and Mary tends him.  Tom and some Buffalo soldiers arrive to the station to arrest Rutledge, who had been seen fleeing the scene of the crime.   When the men learn of the Apache threat, the entire group including Rutledge, now handcuffed, and Mary sets off in pursuit.  After Rutledge shows great bravery in the fight with the Indians, Tom brings him in only to defend him in his court martial.  With Billie Burke, in her last screen appearance, as the judge’s flibberty-jibbet wife.

Woody Strode and the Monument Valley scenery are by far the best things about this movie.  Strode has a natural dignity and presence that are mesmerizing.  The other acting isn’t up to much and I wasn’t particularly fond of the screenplay either.   The shouting at the trial is really overdone and seems false.

Lest anyone think John Wayne could not act, this movie is proof of his abilities.  Jeffrey Hunter falls flat on his face when he attempts to deliver lines clearly written for the Duke in his hard-hitting blustery manner.  I can’t think of another actor who could do better, really.

1960

In 1960:

Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho became the first American film ever to show a toilet flushing on screen. The first of the 5-pointed pink stars in the sidewalk on the “Hollywood Walk of Fame” was unveiled.  It was awarded to actress Joanne Woodward. Billy Wilder’s The Apartment was the last black-and-white film to win the Best Picture Academy Award Oscar until Schindler’s List (1993).

Dalton Trumbo, one of the Hollywood Ten, received full credit for writing the screenplays for Preminger’s Exodus and Kubrick’s Spartacus, thus becoming the first blacklisted writer to receive screen credit. In 1960, Trumbo was also finally reinstated in the Writers Guild of America. This official recognition effectively brought an end to the HUAC ‘blacklist era’.

Clark Gable died of a heart attack (and coronary thrombosis) at the age of 59. Gable was buried at Forest Lawn next to his deceased actress/wife Carole Lombard, who died in an airplane crash in 1942. Art director Cedric Gibbons, who during his long career had won 11 Oscars for Art Direction (from 1929 to 1957) (from a total of 39 nominations), died at the age of 67. Actress Margaret Sullavan, died at the age of 50 of an accidental overdose of barbiturates.

 

Jack Kennedy (L) & Dick Nixon exchanging smiles, standing under glaring lights prior to beginning their 1st TV debate.

John F. Kennedy won the U.S. Presidential election by the narrowest margin in history following the first-ever televised presidential debates. At age 43, he became the second youngest man to serve as President and the youngest man elected to the office.

In Greensboro, North Carolina, four black students from North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University began a sit-in at a segregated Woolworth’s lunch counter. The event triggered many similar non-violent protests throughout the Southern United States, and six months later the original four protesters were served lunch at the same counter. President Dwight D. Eisenhower signed the Civil Rights Act of 1960 into law.

Xerox introduced the first photocopier.  Aluminum cans were used for the first time. “The Twist” dance craze swept the nation.  The FDA approved the first oral contraceptive pill.  President Eisenhower sent 3,500 soldiers into Vietnam.

Advise and Consent by Alan Drury won the Pulizter Prize for fiction.  Fiorello!, book by Jerome Weidman and George Abbot; music by Jerry Bock and Sheldon Harnick, won for Drama.    U.S. Scientists were named Time Magazine’s Men of the Year.    “The Theme from a Summer Place”, an instrumental by Percy Faith and His Orchestra, spent nine weeks atop the Billboard charts.

Still from the Eichmann trial

Seventeen African nations gained independence.  A Soviet missile shot down the US U2 spy plane. Fidel Castro nationalized American oil, sugar and other US interests in Cuba. OPEC ( Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries ) was formed.  Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann was captured by Israeli agents in Argentina.

*******************************

The list of films I will select from for 1960 is here.  I have previously reviewed  on this site.  There’s lots to look forward to!


Montage of stills from Oscar Winners


Montage of stills from nominees in major Oscar categories

The World of Apu (1959)

The World of Apu (Apur Sansar)
Directed by Sayajit Ray
Written by Sayajit Ray from a story by Bibhutibhushan Bandyopadhyay
Sayajit Ray Productions
Repeat viewing/FilmStruck
One of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die

[box] Apurba Roy: I’m invited to a wedding and I come home with the bride![/box]

Ray saved the best in his Apu Trilogy for last.  The film combines great beauty with a sense of real intimacy.

Following the death of his older sister, father and mother in the previous films, Apu must quit college part way through due to lack of funds.  He has shown a considerable talent for writing while still in school and continues to write short stories and a first novel through the film.  He moves to Calcutta to try to find work but it is not easy to find a steady job to supplement the income he earns as a tutor.  Finally he must settle for a factory job totally outside his interests or talents.

Nonetheless, Apu enjoys his life and the new ideas and sights that surround him.  Poverty is not so bad while there is no responsibility that goes with it.

Then Apu’s best friend invites him to attend a relative’s wedding in his home village.  After the men get there, the family discovers the groom selected is “mad”.  Mother refuses to let the marriage go through.  Yet if the daughter is not married that very day, she will become unmarriageable (reason never really explained). The family prevails on a very reluctant Apu to take over groom duties.  He complies and must take his bride, a relative stranger, back to his sordid student quarters in the city.  In spite of everything, love grows fast and marriage is everything Apu could have dreamed it to be.  I think I’ll stop the plot summary right here

I love this movie.  My favorite aspects are the exquisite cinematography and the intimate details of daily existence that Ray manages to capture.  It all seems quite real.  The standard of acting goes up a notch when compared to the first two films.  The story continues to be sad but ends on a note of hope.  Highly recommended.

Clip – print quality on restored version is superb, much better than clip

Arrival

I’m home from an outstanding break birdwatching and catching up with my friend.  This year was especially awesome as there had just been a rainstorm with plenty of flooded fields for the birds to enjoy.  Here are a couple of feeble pictures I took with my iPhone.

Great Egret with Snow Geese, country road, Placer County, California Peregrine Falcon, Sacramento National Wildlife Refuge

While I was at it, I actually saw two movies in the theater!  I can recommend Arrival (2016) for sci-fi buffs.  It’s about a linguist (Amy Adams) whose mission is to communicate with aliens that have popped up all over the planet and figure out why they came.  It has something to do with a message about the non-linearity of time.  Some of it went over my head but the movie is so eerily beautiful that I didn’t care.

The other was Manchester by the Sea (2016).  The acting, by Casey Affleck, Melissa Williams and others, is fantastic and the film is beautiful to look at.  Be prepared for what seems like hours and hours of unrelieved despair, however.  I was just not up for anything quite that depressing.

I’m looking forward to getting back to 1959 where I belong!

 

Off to visit my feathered friends

I’ll be visiting my bird watching friend to see the winter migrants in the Sacramento area.  Will return on December 21.  See you at the movies!

 

Sacramento National Wildlife Refuge

Fires on the Plain (1959)

 

Fires on the Plain (Nobi)fires-dvd
Directed by Kon Ichikawa
Written by Nata Wada from a novel by Shohei Ooka
1959/Japan
Daiei Studios/Kadokawa Herald Pictures
First viewing/Netflix rental

Quartermaster: Kill yourself only if you have to. Here are some rations.

There are some images I would rather not have indelibly etched upon my memory.  This film contains several.

It is February 1945 on Leyte in the Philippines. MacArthur has returned and the U.S. is engaged in a mopping up operation.  PFC Tamura has TB.  The hospital sent him back to his unit with a few yams.  His squad commander doesn’t want an extra mouth to feed either.  He hands him a grenade and tells him if the hospital won’t take him back Tamura should kill himself.  Tamura is nothing if not dutiful but he can’t quite bring himself to suicide.

fires-1

The hospital won’t take anyone who can still walk.  Tamura spends the remainder of the film wandering, sometimes alone and sometimes with companions.  All are slowly starving to death and resort to increasingly horrifying acts of barbarity.

fop5

I loved Ichikawa’s The Burmese Harp so I was looking forward to his other acclaimed WWII film.  From the blurb, it sounded like Tamura would be a noble figure like the hero in the former film.  Instead, Tamura is merely the least repugnant of survivors who are alive only because of their ruthlessness.  I couldn’t help feeling pity for the men, and the images are stunning, but the whole thing is so hellish that I can’t see watching this again.

Clip

Eastward Bound

I will be on hiatus until October 31 for a road trip to see my niece in Provo, Utah, with some Las Vegas thrown in on the margins.  See you then!

 

Something exciting for U.S. movie-lovers

I subscribe to the Criterion Collection newsletter and have breaking news.  The collection is moving to Filmstruck, a new streaming service, from its current home on Hulu.  The new service will be co-curated by Criterion Collection and Turner Classic Movies and will focus on hard-to-find films.  For me, the most exciting aspect of the service will be the ability to get commentary tracks via streaming.   I’ve been waiting for that to happen.  The first to launch will apparently be the out-of-print commentary track to The Silence of the Lambs.

I try not to spam my readers but I just had to share this.

You can sign up to get a free two-week subscription when the service launches on October 19 here.  Criterion’s announcement is here.

The Square Peg (1958)

The Square Peg
Directed by John Paddy Carstairs
Written by Jack Davies, Henry Blyth, Norman Wisdom, and Eddie Leslie
1958/UK
The Rank Organization
First viewing/YouTube

[box] I can never tell a joke, I’ve always found it easier to just fall over. — Norman Wisdom[/box]

For me, this was watchable but not hilariously funny.

The world of Norman Pittman (Norman Wisdom) revolves around his work as a road repairman and his boss Mr. Grimsdale.  He thinks that this is far more important than WWII and refuses to back down to officers.  Eventually, it becomes apparent that the only way to beat Norman is to make him join up.  A series of misadventures takes Norman and Grimsdale to France, where Norman’s resemblance to a German general leads to danger and hijinx. With Honor Blackman as a pretty spy.

I find Wisdom more irritating than endearing, unfortunately.  Most of the gags are built around cheekiness and he takes it just that bit too far each time.  The humor does not seem to have translated well across time and culture.

Trailer

The Proud Rebel (1958)

The Proud Rebel
Directed by Michael Curtiz
Written by Joseph Petracca and Lillie Hayward from a story by James Edward Grant
1958/USA
Formosa Productions
First viewing/Amazon Prime

[box] Jeb Burleigh: I’d like a little respect. I told you before I don’t like people I’m talkin’ to to walk away from me. Look at me! You look at me when I talk to you.

John Chandler: I’m lookin’, but I don’t see anything.[/box]

This is a solid, if predictable, family Western with some good performances and some mean hombres.

John Chandler (Alan Ladd) is a man of few words.  His son David (David Ladd) lost his speech when their Georgia plantation was destroyed and his mother killed during the Civil War.  John is now traveling through the North with David and their beloved sheepdog, Lance, desperately seeking a cure for his son’s muteness.  They are very short on cash.

Almost as soon they arrive in town, the Burleigh brothers attempt to steal Lance and then pick a fight.  John decks Jeb Burleigh and is arrested for assault.  The court is stacked against him and he is sentenced to $30 or 30 days.  This is money he does not have nor can he leave David alone while he serves time.  Fortunately, spinster Linnett Moore (Olivia de Havilland), who has had her own trouble with the Burleighs, pays the fine and he agrees to work off the loan on her farm.

The Burleighs are sheep ranchers and Linnett’s farm denies them open pasture that they covet.  Father Harry Burleigh (Dean Jagger) is smoother than his sons but they all would do anything to drive her from her farm.  With John by her side, Linnett is more stubborn than ever.  The two develop a warm friendship that could turn into something more.

John learns that there is a doctor at the Mayo Clinic who thinks he has a 50-50 chance of curing David.  It will cost $300.  John could earn the money by selling the amazing Lance but that would break David’s heart.

I love sheepdogs and I would have watched this movie just to see that dog work those sheep.  Fortunately, the movie is solid all around and de Havilland is particularly impressive.   Of course, you don’t have to be a genius to anticipate virtually every one of the plot points.

Clip