Category Archives: 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die

Reviews of movies included in the book 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die

It’s a Gift (1934)

It’s a Giftits_a_gift DVD
Directed by Norman Z. McLeod
1934/USA
Paramount Pictures

#81 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
Second viewing

 

W.C. Fields plays Harold Bisonette (that’s Biso-NAY when his wife’s around). The hen-pecked Bisonette owns a corner grocery but dreams of moving to California and running an orange ranch. His uncle dies and leaves him the money to move his family West, much to their disgust. The orange grove turns out to be a bust but there is always a happy ending in a W.C. Fields movie.

Harry Payne Bosterly: You’re drunk!
Harold: And you’re crazy. But I’ll be sober tomorrow and you’ll be crazy for the rest of your life.

It's a Gift 3

I have been trying to figure out why Fields just isn’t funny to me. I think he lets each of his gags run on too long and telegraphs them too obviously. Also much of the humor relies on destruction, irritating noises, etc., which I find more annoying than comic. Finally this movie has a scene of food humor toward the end. I can’t help it, I just find anything involving making a mess with food more disgusting than anything else.

This is one of the 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die. The only reason I can find is that W.C. Fields is a name everybody has probably heard of. I now have seen this film twice and that’s more than enough for one lifetime.

The porch scene (Karl L-a-F-o-n-g)

Make Way for Tomorrow (1937)

Make Way for Tomorrowmakewayfortomorrow-2009criteriondvd
Directed by Leo McCarey
1937/USA
Paramount Pictures

#109 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
First Viewing

 

I watched this as a companion piece to Ozu’s Tokyo Story, with which it is thematically linked.  Both films deal with relations between parents and their adult children.  This film confronts the issue more directly as the children are faced with having to care for their parents in old age.  It is also one of the few films to portray married love in the sunset of life.  Although it is a more sentimental story, it is also an excellent film.

Make Way for Tomorrow 3

The children are stunned at the news that the parents have to leave their home in two days.

Lucy and Barkley Cooper have been happily married for 50 years when the bank forecloses on their home. Since none of their five children is willing to take both of them, Lucy (Beulah Bondi) settles with a son in New York City and Bark (Victor Moore) settles with a daughter 300 miles away in the country.  Things don’t work out well for anyone concerned, as the parents disrupt their children’s’ established routines and the couple pine for each other.  They are allowed a second honeymoon in New York City before being again separated, perhaps forever.

Mr. Horton, Hotel Manager: Have you any children?
Pa: Five of them.
Mr. Horton, Hotel manager: Really! I’ll bet they’ve brought you a lot of pleasure!
Pa: [Ironically] I bet you haven’t any children.

This is a really heartbreaking film. I think I felt the saddest that the couple, who so clearly loved and needed each other, had to be separated. The children meant well but every one of them put their own needs first. I don’t think I’ll ever be able to listen to “Let Me Call You Sweetheart” again without getting tears in my eyes.  Beulah Bondi and Victor Moore do an excellent job of portraying characters 20 years older than their actual age without once going over the top.

A fond farewll

A fond farewell

I kept thinking about what a difference social security could have made in this couple’s life.  After all, these people were basically healthy and able to care for themselves.  They just had no steady income and no prospect of finding employment.  Social Security was enacted in 1935 and implemented in 1937.  The film historian who presented a video essay on the Criterion DVD said that the film makes a powerful argument for old age insurance without ever mentioning it.  I agree.

Trailer

David Holzman’s Diary (1967)

David Holzman’s Diarydavid-holzmans-diary-movie-poster
Directed by Jim McBride
1967/USA
Produced by Jim McBride

#486 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
First viewing

I ran out of 1934 rentals to watch so I picked this at random because it was on Netflix streaming. First, let me say that I was really glad I knew absolutely nothing about this film when I put it on. There are many surprises that shouldn’t be spoiled.

“Le cinéma, c’est vingt-quatre fois la vérité par seconde.” ― Jean-Luc Godard

It is New York City in 1967. A young film maker has just lost his job and received a draft notice.  He decides he will film his life in hopes to understand it better. He has faith in the Godard quote “Film is truth 24 times per second” and thinks that he may be able to connect with objects, events, and people by capturing them on celluloid.

The narrator’s girlfriend is an important part of his life so he keeps filming her at random times, including while she is sleeping nude. She rapidly calls their relationship off but he continues to more or less stalk her for the rest of the film. He also captures the atmosphere of his neighborhood and the people there, spies on a woman in an apartment across the street, follows a random woman leaving the subway, gets propositioned by  a transvestite, etc., etc.
David Holzman's Diary 5The soundtrack includes a lot of TV and radio news which gives a real flavor of the time. There is a fantastic sequence of high-speed shots from all the TV shows he watched one night that is like a mini time capsule.  In between the street photography, there are lots of times where the guy just rants to the camera. In the end, he is disappointed that his film did not explain his life.  I think the audience is a lot more able to spot his gradual disintegration than he is.

I’m not able to describe this very well and it may sound boring but I was fascinated throughout. (It helps that the movie is only 74 minutes long.)

David Holzman's Diary 1SPOILER: Well, this film’s claim to fame is that it is a fake documentary/satire but I didn’t know that and I was surprised when the credits started rolling. This made me even more impressed with the film. It is so cleverly done.

“Every edit is a lie.” ― Jean-Luc Godard

Admittedly, there were some parts where I was asking myself a) how did this guy get so much money to buy equipment and live on the Upper West Side of Manhattan?; b) who is filming him? c) did all these unwilling victims of his photography sue him? d) why would somebody release such an unflattering picture of himself? At any rate, the film makers tricked me into believing it was a documentary.  This would make a good companion piece to Buñuel’s Land Without Bread,  I definitely liked this one better than that, though.

This film was selected to the National Film Registry, Library of Congress, in 1991. Must one see this before one dies?   I don’t know if I would go that far but I did enjoy it and I know I’ll think about it.

Clip – “watching television”

 

The 39 Steps (1935)

The 39 Steps39 steps blu-ray
Directed by Alfred Hitchcock
1935/UK
Gaumont British Picture Corporation

#91 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
Multiple Viewings
IMDb users say 7.9; I say 9.0

 

The 39 Steps showcases Hitchcock as a master craftsman relatively early in his career. If the definition of a classic is a work that remains entertaining and surprising over time and repeated exposure, this film certainly deserves to be called one.

I revisited The Thirty-Nine Steps with the Blu-Ray disc from the Criterion Collection, which can be rented from Netflix.  The film has probably never looked more beautiful and is packaged with a number of extras including a commentary, a documentary on Hitchcock’s British films, a video interview with Hitchcock, a visual essay on the film by Leonard Leff, and audio excerpts about the film from  François Truffaut’s 1962 interviews with Hitchcock.

The story should be familiar to any Hitchcock lover, if not from this film, from many that follow such as Saboteur and North by Northwest.  In this classic plot, a man is falsely accused of a crime and must flee both the police and the true criminals while attempting to clear his name.

Here our story begins when Richard Hannay (Robert Donat) visits a musical hall and catches the act of Mr. Memory, a man with reams of trivia at his disposal.   The way Hitchcock builds suspense by quick cuts between audience members shouting out questions in this scene is stunning.  The scene ends with a scuffle and gunshots.

39 steps 4

Hannay meets a woman as he is exiting the music hall.  She says she needs protection so he takes her to his apartment.  The woman is a spy on the trail of “The 39 Steps” and tells Hannay she has little time to prevent a valuable secret from leaving the country. She is promptly murdered in the apartment and Hannay is the prime suspect. Thus, begins his desperate flight from the police and quest to stop the spy ring.

Richard Hannay: Beautiful, mysterious woman pursued by gunmen. Sounds like a spy story.
Annabella Smith: That’s exactly what it is.

Hannay heads for Scotland based on a map he finds in the woman’s dead hand.  On his way, he spends the night with a crofter and his wife.  This scene is like its own short film about a jealous farmer (John Lurie), his much younger wife (Peggy Ashcroft), and a dashing young traveller.  It is a short scene but Hitchcock manages to pack in quite a bit of pathos and psychological depth to the predicament of a woman trapped in a bad marriage.

39 steps 3

With the police hot on his heels, Hannay meets The Professor and barely escapes with his life.

The 39 Steps

On the run again, Hannay finds himself the main speaker at a political rally and must improvise.  This scene would be copied many times, most notably in The Third Man.  He meets Pamela (Madeleine Carroll) and they are both abducted by bad guys who eventually handcuff them together.

The third act plays as a sort of romantic comedy with the two sparring mightily before they fall in love.  Hitchcock is able to work in some slightly racy material when the two are forced to share a bedroom.  I hate to give away the ending of a 78-year-old movie so I will stop here.  Suffice it to say that the film ends on this shot.

39 steps 5

I’ve seen this one many times. The famous set pieces (Mr. Memory, the little finger, the handcuff scene in the inn) are indelibly imprinted in my memory. Yet I was surprised how fresh the story remains.  It is also a pleasure to enjoy the performance of Robert Donat, a consummate movie actor.  He said the secret of his success was his ability to be still and watching him just listen and think is a treat.  I prefer The Lady Vanishes among Hitchcock’s British films , but this ranks just behind it. It remains a witty and stylish suspense thriller.

Criterion – Three Reasons:  The 39 Steps

A Trip to the Moon (1902)

A Trip to the Moon (“Le voyage dans la lune”)  The Movies Begin DVD
Directed by Georges Méliès
1902/France
Star-Film

#1 of 1001 Films You Must See Before You Die
Multiple Viewings
IMDb users say 8.2/10; I say 9.0/10

 

I thought I’d catch up on some past 1001 Movie Blog Club selections.  What more natural place to start than with the first movie on the list?  As an added bonus, I finally got to see the restored hand-colored version with some additional footage I had never seen.  The restoration, music, and added footage only add to the film’s charm.   I had always thought of this movie as a landmark of early cinema but this viewing had me laughing out loud at some of the ridiculous antics Méliès presents.

Our story begins at a meeting of astronomers.  Their president proposes a trip to the moon.  He gets a generally enthusiastic reception but one of the astronomers objects and the president pelts the culprit with books and papers.  Four astronomers are selected to join the president on the voyage.  The group goes to inspect the spacecraft, which is shaped like a giant bullet.  It will be launched from a cannon and we see the gun being casted.  A bevy of beauties in tights serve as gunners for the launch.  (Méliès uses every opportunity to feature shapely ladies throughout.)

trip to the moon 5

The spaceship is successfully launched.  In one of the most iconic images in film history, it pierces the eye of the moon.

trip to the moon 4

The astronauts are tired from their journey and stretch out on the moon’s surface for a nap.  They dream that women in the stars are scolding them for violating the moon.  Phoebus in the form of a lady in the crescent moon sends snow to show the displeasure of the cosmos.  The astronauts are cold and foolishly decide to descend into a crater.  There they find a grotto filled with giant mushrooms.  A vengeful group of moon dwellers called Selenites attack our heroes.  Fortunately, these disappear into a puff of smoke when struck by an umbrella.  Nonetheless, the a mob of Selenites chase the astronauts into the presence of their king but he also is despatched with an umbrella.  The president sacrifices his life to save the other astronauts by staying behind to push the spacecraft off the edge of the moon.  The spacecraft lands in the ocean, where it floats, and is rescued by a steamer.

This is where the film ended in previous versions I watched.  The restored version continues on with a couple of very charming scenes showing the heroic welcome greeting the astronauts.  I am crazy about the monument built in their honor.

trip to the moon 6

The restoration I watched was based on an original hand-colored print of A Trip to the Moon rediscovered in 1993 by the Filmoteca de Catalunya. Technicolor Lab of Los Angeles launched a frame-by-frame restoration of the almost totally decomposed print in 1999 and completed it in 2010.   Afterwards, West Wing Digital Studios replaced missing frames by hand painting frames from a black and white print. The restored version finally premiered at the 2011 Cannes Film Festival, with a new soundtrack by the French band Air.  It was released in 2012 by Flicker Alley in a 2-disc Blu-Ray/DVD edition, which included  the documentary The Extraordinary Voyage about its restoration.  I’d like to see that DVD edition sometime. The restoration is no longer available on YouTube or via Wikipedia.

Complete black and white film with a modern score.

The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938

The Adventures of Robin Hoodadventures-of-robin-hood-DVDcover
Directed by Michael Curtiz and William Keighley
1938/USA
Warner Bros. Pictures

#114 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die
Second Viewing
IMDb users say 8.0/10; I say 9.0/10

Lady Marian Fitzswalter: Why, you speak treason!
Robin Hood: Fluently.

There are times that call for uncomplicated entertainment where virtue triumphs and true love prospers.  The Great Depression was such a time.  I would submit that the 2010’s are another, which may account for the current popularity of Superhero comic book fare.  Since I prefer my films without explosions, graphic violence or CGI, The Adventures of Robin Hood is where I want to turn when I’m looking for an action pick-me-up.

Adventures of Robin Hood

True Love

Whatever his personal life, in 1938 Errol Flynn was the embodiment of swashbuckling, wise-cracking virtue and perfect for playing Robin Hood as the merriest of the Merry Men. We meet him as he is rescuing poacher Much from summary execution by the coldly cruel Sir Guy of Gisbourne (Basil Rathbone).  However, his grand entrance is shortly afterward when he arrives at a banquet hosted by Prince John (Claude Raines) and deposits the poached deer before the prince.  This is followed by a classic fight scene in which Robin fights off at least 20 Norman foes single handed with sword, arrows, and sheer derring-do.

adventuresofrobinhood with deer

Robin first sets eyes on the beautiful Lady Marian, intelligently played by the lovely Olivia de Havilland, at the banquet.  As a Norman, she at first despises this Saxon upstart but learns to respect and then love him for his loyalty to her guardian King Richard and his goodness to the downtrodden.  Robin is appropriately chivalric throughout.  In fact, a tenant of the oath taken by the  Merry Men is to protect all women whether Norman or Saxon.

Three Villains - Melville Cooper, Basil Rathbone, and Claude Raines

Three villains – Melville Cooper, Basil Rathbone, and Claude Raines

The supporting cast is a roster of some of the most familiar faces in ’30’s Hollywood. Each villain has his own consistent attributes from Claude Raines’s cynical, snide Prince John, to Melville Cooper’s cowardly Sheriff of Nottingham.  Basil Rathbone contributes his expert swordsmanship to the fabulous sword duel with Robin that closes the film.  Then we have the good guys.  It is hard to imagine a more perfect crew than Alan Hale as Little John, Eugene Pallette as Friar Tuck, Patric Knowles as Will Scarlet, and Herbert Mundin as Much.   Una O’Conner hams it up as Marian’s loyal lady’s maid Bess.

Adventures of Robin Hood Climactic Duel

The bright glittering costumes and sets may not present an accurate picture of the Middle Ages but they do contribute to the storybook feeling of the piece.  Those who are looking for a gritty, nuanced portrayal of the Robin Hood legend would do better elsewhere.  Those viewers who are out for a good time can stop right here for 102 minutes of unadulterated fun.

Clip – The Archery Tournament

 

L’Atalante

L’Atalantel'atalante dvd
Directed by Jean Vigo
France, 1934
Gaumont-Franco Film-Aubert
Second viewing

 

 

 Juliette – “Don’t you know? In the water we can see the one we love.”

A young skipper brings his new bride (Dita Parlo) aboard his small barge to live with his eccentric first mate (Michel Simon), a boy, and too many rambunctious cats. We witness the couple’s initial passion, the wife’s boredom, the husband’s jealousy, and then the cycle begins again. The slight plot is told in vivid images that insinuate themselves in the memory. Dita Parlo brings an enchanting sense of wonder to her character. This is a totally original, funny, and erotic story that engaged me throughout.  The last of Jean Vigo’s four films before his death at age 29 and a masterpiece.

 

It Happened One Night

 It Happened One Nightit happened dvd
Directed by Frank Capra
USA, 1934
Columbia Pictures Corporation
Umpteenth viewing
1001 Movies – #86

 

It Happened One Night

Peter Warne: “I want to see what love looks like when it’s triumphant. I haven’t had a good laugh in a week.”

This is my idea of cinematic perfection as produced by Hollywood in 1934.  There is not one single thing I would change.  Of course, the leads are fabulous but every character actor was the best possible that could have been found.  Once seen, Roscoe Karns’ annoying Shapley, Alan Hale’s larcenous flivver driver Danker, and Walter Connelly’s autocratic but loving father will become old friends.  Capra, too, had a light touch which he was never again to entirely replicate.  My favorite part is “The Man on the Flying Trapeze” scene on the bus.

66 movies I hope to watch for 1934:  http://www.imdb.com/list/fmXidXs5FOE/