Show Boat (1936)

Show Boat
Directed by James Whale
Written by Oscar Hammerstein II based on the novel by Edna Ferber
1936/USA
Universal Pictures

First viewing

[box] Joe: [singing] I gits weary / An’ sick o’ tryin’ / I’m tired o’ livin’ / An’ scared o’ dyin’ / But Ol’ Man River / He jes’ keeps rollin’ along![/box]

Oh, how I loved, loved, loved this screen adaptation of the Jerome Kern and Oscar Hammerstein 1927 Broadway musical!

Captain Andy Hawks (Charles Winniger) runs a show boat on the Mississippi River.  His leading lady Julie (Helen Morgan) and leading man Steve are married.  A jealous boat hand reveals that Julie has negro blood and she and Steve leave the boat under charges of miscegenation.  Captain Andy’s daughter Magnolia (Irene Dunne) takes over for Julie.  Riverboat gambler Gaylord Ravenal needs to get out of town and hitches a ride on the show boat, taking over from Steve as leading man.  He and Magnolia fall in love and marry but things take a turn for the worse when Gay tries to support her with his gambling winnings.  With Paul Robeson as Joe and Hattie McDaniel as Queenie.

I love this film so much that I sat rapt through a 16-part YouTube viewing of the movie, the only means that was available to me.  The story gets pretty melodramatic by the end but the musical numbers are just perfect.  Three of them gave me chills:  Robeson’s rendition of “Ol’ Man River”; the ensemble “Can’t Help Lovin’ Dat Man”; and Helen Morgan’s “Bill”.

This was James Whale’s favorite of all his pictures and I think he was right.  It is certainly beautifully staged.  The casting is wonderful.  I like Irene Dunne better every time I see her. In fact the only thing I can find fault with was the decision to cut several of the stage show’s songs in favor of original numbers.   I could gush on and on.

It is criminal that there has never been a DVD of this film.  It is vastly superior to the 1951 version, which is readily available.

Clip – “Can’t Help Lovin’ Dat Man” (gives me the chills! — when Robeson joins in behind the women)

Mr. Thank You (1936)

Mr. Thank You (“Arigatô-san”)
Directed by Hiroshi Shimizu
Written by Hiroshi Shimizu from a novel by Yasunari Kawabata
1936/Japan
Shochiku Ofuna

First viewing

 

[box] Mr. Thank You: So far this fall, I’ve seen eight girls cross this pass headed for paper factories and cotton mills and who knows what else. Sometimes I think I’d be better off driving a hearse.[/box]

 

I loved this slice of life of Depression-era rural Japan.

Mr. Thank You is a bus driver and got his name from his cheerful “thank you” called out as miscellaneous foot traffic gets out of his way on the mountain roads he travels.  The film covers just one bus journey from a small coastal town to a train station on the other side of the mountains.  The train will take a 17-year-old girl to Tokyo where she will go into some apparently shameful form of employment.  She is accompanied by her mother.  Also on the bus is a young woman of the world who calls herself a “migratory bird” and has her eye on Mr. Thank You and a rather obnoxious man in a fake handlebar mustache who has his eye on the girl.

Many other passengers get on and off the bus en route.  Mr. Thank You is well known to the people who live along his route and does small favors for them such as carrying messages or picking up records of popular music.  There is a thread of plot involving the principal passengers but mostly the film is presented in vignettes of small everyday occurances.

I love to get a glimpse of what real life was like long ago and far away and this film beautifully gave me one.  Somehow Shimizu does this and transcends what could otherwise be a travelogue.  All the incidents are so vivid that I was fully engaged the whole time.  Highly recommended.

Clip

The Milky Way (1936)

The Milky Way
Directed by Leo McCarey
Written by Grover Jones, Frank Butler, and Richard Connell
1936/USA
Paramount Pictures

First viewing

 

[box] [when asked whether the transition from silents to sound made any problems because of his voice, as with so many other stars from the era] I had to work a little on my voice because I hadn’t used it for years. I went to a voice coach for about five days, and then he said, “Good-bye, you just weren’t using it right”. — Harold Lloyd[/box]

Leo McCarey ensures that this is funnier than your average comedy.

Burleigh Sullivan (Harold Lloyd) is a mild-mannered milkman with well-developed skills in ducking to avoid punches.  One day, he confronts a couple of men who are harassing his sister.  During the incident, on of the men, who turns out to be the heavyweight champion of the world, gets knocked out.  The fighter’s manager (Adolphe Menjou) decides the only way to salvage his man’s reputation is to build up Burleigh and then let the fighter knock him out in a championship bout.  With Verree Teasdale as the manager’s wisecracking girlfriend and William Gargan as the champ’s sparring partner.

A lot of this is quite silly but there is enough inspired screwball dialogue for a good time.  Harold Lloyd’s physical antics are also frequently amusing.  I attribute the film’s success to McCarey who always gives a very enjoyable improvisational feel to his work.

Samuel Goldwyn bought the rights,  original negative, and almost all existing prints and destroyed them when he remade the story as The Kid from Brooklyn, starring Danny Kaye.  The film fell into the public domain and the print I watched on Amazon Prime Watch Instant left a lot to be desired.

Clip

Osaka Elegy (1936)

Osaka Elegy (“Naniwa erejî”)
Directed by Kenji Mizoguchi
Written by Kenji Mizoguchi, Yoshikata Yoda and Tadashi Fujiwara
1936/Japan
Daiichi Eiga

First viewing

 

It’s not easy to “like” this thoroughly depressing film.  Nonetheless, it is darkly magnificent.

Mr. Asai is a whiny, complaining old man who gives his servant girls nothing but grief and is picked on by his wealthy wife.  Ayako (Isuzu Yamada) is a telephone operator who works for him.  Mr. Asai constantly propositions Ayako but she is in love with a co-worker.

Ayako’s spineless father has embezzled 300 yen from his company.  The company is threatening to prosecute unless he repays the money.  Although Ayako berates him mercilessly, she also desperately wants to get the money to save him from jail.  Her boyfriend cannot help her so she finally gives Mr. Asai what he wants.  She repays the company and Mr. Asai gives her father a job.  The affair is quickly discovered by Asai’s wife.

Later, Ayako gets money to help her brother with his tuition at university by promising her favors to another executive.  When she refuses to follow through, the executive gets her arrested.  Her boyfriend leaves her.  Her family disowns her and calls her an “ingrate”, not even acknowledging her help.  With Takashi Shimura (Ikuru, Seven Samurai) in a small role as a police inspector.

Mizoguchi was the champion of suffering women throughout his career and Osaka Elegy is an early example of this trend.  The problem for me is that Ayako, though strong, is not particularly sympathetic.  While secretly planning to help, she is always very caustic to her family members.  She is mean to the executive.  So I had a nagging feeling the whole time that she brought a lot of this on herself.   On the other hand, I’m not Japanese and don’t know whether filial piety almost required Ayako to avoid shame on her family at all costs.  If so, her body was all she had to bargain with.  This might make anybody hard to get along with.

Whatever reservations I might have about the plot, the film itself cannot be faulted.  Ayako and her boss watch a wonderful Kabuki puppet performance with thematic ties to her plight that I really, really loved.

Lead actress Isuzu Yamada may be most famous for her chilling performance as Lady Asaji Washizu, the Lady Macbeth role in Akira Kurosawa’s Throne of Blood (1957).

Clip – ending

Easy Money (1936)

Easy Money
Directed by Phil Rosen
Written by Arthur T. Horman et al
1936/USA
Invincible Pictures Corp.

First viewing

 

I’ve been unable to find much information about this decent poverty-row production.

Dan Adams works for the District Attorney and loses the prosecution of a man for insurance fraud.  It turns out he threw the case because the defendant was his brother. He resigns his position and gets a job with an insurance company(!) to flush out the big wheels behind the false claim ring, which has been operating under the front of an interior decorating business.  Along the way he falls in love with a claims adjuster.  The audience’s expectations are not challenged by the plot.

 

Photo of Onslow Stevens – film unknown

Easy Money is not a bad little police procedural type story, though nothing to write home about. This was the kind of thing that developed into film noir in the 40’s when the German immigrant directors got their hands on it.  I caught it on Amazon Prime Watch Instant for free.

Winterset (1936)

Winterset
Directed by Alfred Santell
Written by Anthony Veiller based on the play by Maxwell Anderson
1936/USA
RKO Radio Pictures

First viewing

[box] When we’re young we have faith in what is seen, but when we’re old we know that what is seen is traced in air and built on water.  — Maxwell Anderson, Winterset[/box]

This film marked Burgess Meredith’s first credited screen appearance in a role he had played on Broadway.  It is not cinematically well-rendered but is worth seeing as a typical Depression-era social commentary and for the acting.

The story begins in a 1920 New York City tenament where radical Bartolomeo Romagna (John Carradine) and his family discover their car has been stolen, along with the revolutionary pamphlets and other materials in it.  The car is then involved in the killing of the paymaster of the company at which Romagna works.  Romagna is tried for the crime and sentenced to death based on this circumstantial evidence.  His final words to the judge are to the effect that he is to be pitied since he is killing an innocent man and will carry the burden for the rest of his life.

Segue to 1936.  A law school class examines the evidence and decides that Romagna was not shown to be guilty.  A key reason behind its finding is that a man by the name of Garth Esdras witnessed the crime but was never called to testify.  Romagna’s son, Mio (Burgess Merideth) reads the article and travels to New York hoping to track down Esdras.  Merideth has been obsessed by the execution of his father all his life.

It is here that the coincidences start to pile on inexorably.  Mio meets Garth’s sister, not knowing who she is, and it is love at first sight.  The judge at Romagna’s trial has become unhinged and is now investigating in the hope that he will be vindicated.  The mastermind behind the payroll robbery has been released from jail, is critically ill, and is out to mow down anybody who could possibly prove that he had anything to do with the crime.  They all wind up in the tenement apartment of Garth’s father.

Merideth is unbelievably young and good-looking in this.  All the actors are very accomplished.  The dialogue is too poetic to ever have been spoken by a living human but is powerful.    It’s an interesting period piece that kept me engaged throughout its 77 minute running time.

Winterset was nominated by the Academy for Best Score and Best Art Direction.  It won an award for Best Cinematography at the Venice Film Festival and director Santell was nominated at the Festival for the Mussolini Cup.

The Story of a Cheat (1936)

The Story of a Cheat (“Le roman d’un tricheur”)
Directed by Sacha Guitry
Written by Sacha Guitry
1936/France
Cinéas

First viewing
#103 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die

[box] “You can pretend to be serious; but you can’t pretend to be witty.” — Sacha Guitry [/box]

I enjoyed the witty story without becoming immersed in it.

This film is an exercise more in style than in plot.  The story goes something like this.  The anonymous narrator sits in a Parisian café writing his memoirs.  He was born a peasant in a village.  As a boy he lived in an extended family of twelve people.  Because he stole money from the till of their store, he was forbidden to eat from a dish of wild mushrooms at dinner. Thus, he becomes the only one of his family not to die from eating the deadly batch.  An orphan, he is taken by his conniving aunt and uncle who cheat him of his inheritance.  One day, his aunt intentionally leaves a few francs on the table.  He resists the temptation to take them and the aunt surreptitiously leaves him an ad for employment as a doorman at a fancy hotel.  He takes the cue to run away. So begins a series of jobs ending as a croupier in Monte Carlo and a number of amorous adventures as a sometime gambling cheat and thief.

 

This movie is a lot of fun.  There is almost no dialogue other than the voice-over recounting the memoir.  The setting is highly theatrical in that the audience is distanced from the action, which feels artificial.  Everything is kept very light.  The credits are presented in the most original way I have yet seen!  This was the first film I have seen by Guitry.  I look forward to seeing others.  Recommended.

Trailer (no subtitles, unfortunately)

A Day in the Country (1936)

A Day in the Country (“Partie de campagne”) 
Directed by Jean Renoir
Written by Jean Renoir based on a short story by Guy de Maupassant
1936/France
Panthéon Productions

First viewing
#94 of 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die

 

[box] “The kiss itself is immortal. It travels from lip to lip, century to century, from age to age. Men and women garner these kisses, offer them to others and then die in turn.” ― Guy de Maupassant, The Complete Short Stories of Guy de Maupassant, Part One[/box]

Jean Renoir’s third film of 1936 is an unfinished jewel that makes up in atmosphere and emotion what it lacks in characterization and story.

The Dufours are Parisian dairy owners.  Father, mother, daughter and shop boy take an annual trip to the country one Sunday where they stop at a riverside inn for lunch. Henrietta, the daughter, is enchanted by the beauty of the setting, which awakens in her an inexpressible tenderness.  Two young men are also dining at the inn.  After lunch, they provide the father and shop assistant with fishing poles and offer to take the ladies rowing.  Henri takes Henrietta to his secret grove of trees where they kiss.  With Jean Renoir in a small part as the owner of the inn.

Renoir evokes the essence of a lazy summer day with his camerawork, which is just gorgeous.  The music, too, reflects the fullness in Henrietta’s heart.  In fact, the whole ambience has the feeling of Renoir’s father the impressionist painter.  I imagine it was for this reason that the film was selected for The List.  Otherwise, I don’t understand why one of the other two excellent 1936 films, The Crime of Monsieur Lange or The Lower Depths were not chosen.  Those reflect completed work and are far more substantial than this one, which is a little farcical in the early parts for my taste.

Clip

Our Relations (1936)

Our Relations
Directed by Harry Lachman
Written by Richard Connell, Felix Adler, et al
1936/USA
Hal Roach Studios/Metro-Goldwyn-Meyer
First viewing

 

[box] Finn: [hands Ollie a bill] Here, have yourselves a fling. Ollie: A dollar? We can’t do much flinging on a dollar.[/box]

I found most of this uninspired until the very end when a sight gag involving Stan and Ollie bobbing around like roly-poly dolls with their feet in cement had me roaring  with laughter.

Stan and Ollie’s long-lost twin brothers Alf and Bertie are sailors.  Unbeknownst to our heroes they show up penniless in town and set in motion all kinds of nonsense involving mistaken identities and a valuable ringing belonging to the captain of the ship.  With Alan Hale as a beer-garden owner.

Clip

The Story of Louis Pasteur

The Story of Louis Pasteur
Directed by William Dieterle
Written by Sheridan Gibney and Pierre Collings
1936/USA
First National Productions

First viewing

 

[box] Dr. Louis Pasteur: [to his assistants] Remember our aim: Find the microbe – kill the microbe.[/box]

I enjoyed this inspiring biopic and Paul Muni’s perfomance as the French scientist.

Irascible French chemist Louis Pasteur fights for years to have his theory that microbes cause disease accepted by the French medical establishment.  His theory helps him to discover a vaccine for anthrax and a cure for rabies.

Despite the dry sounding subject matter, my eyes were wet by the end.  It is amazing how helpless medicine was against disease and how vulnerable people were to infection by dirty hands and instruments before Pasteur’s breakthrough (which, admittedly was paralleled by Lister’s work on antiseptic surgery in Britain).  Muni absolutely disappears into his character.  Recommended.

Muni won an Academy Award for Best Actor, while Collings and Gibney won for Best Screenplay and Best Story. The film was nominated for Best Picture.

Trailer